The Black Collar Crime Series relies on public news stories and publicly available information for its content. If any incorrect information is found, please contact Bruce Gerencser. Nothing in this post should be construed as an accusation of guilt. Those accused of crimes are innocent until proven guilty.
In 2022, Jordan Huffman, a former youth pastor at Woodlands Church in Plover, Wisconsin, was accused of sexually assaulting a church teenager. The sexual assaults began when the boy was twelve. Huffman also worked for Forest Lakes District Evangelical Free Church of America in Stevens Point, Wisconsin.
The Stevens Point Journal reported:
Jordan Ross Huffman, 51, who is living in Satellite Beach, Florida, faces charges of first-degree sexual assault of a child, two counts of repeated sexual assault of a child, three counts of child enticement, one count of causing a child to view sexual activity and one count of contributing to the delinquency of a child.
The Portage County District Attorney’s Office filed the charges against Huffman on Aug. 5, and Portage County Circuit Judge Louis Molepske Jr. issued a warrant for him on Monday.
The Brevard County, Florida, Sheriff’s Office online records state officers arrested Huffman Tuesday. On Wednesday, Attorney Andrea Winder, of Madison, notified the court that she is Huffman’s lawyer.
According to the criminal complaint, in 2017, a couple approached Huffman, who at the time was a pastor at Woodlands Church in Plover, and asked him to mentor their 12-year-old son. The boy had started drinking and getting into trouble.
The boy told police instead of helping him, Huffman did just the opposite, according to the complaint. Huffman gave the boy alcohol, marijuana and prescription pills, according to the complaint. The boy said Huffman would drive him to a remote location at the end of a dirt road, after the boy was drunk or under the influence of marijuana, and inappropriately touch the boy with his mouth or hands, according to the complaint.
The boy said the encounters happened multiple times. He said nothing happened at Woodlands Church, other than Huffman telling the boy he had alcohol, marijuana or nicotine cartridges for him, according to the complaint. He said Huffman had sexual intercourse with him one time at Huffman’s home while his wife and children were gone.
When Huffman left Woodlands Church and took a job with Forest Lakes District Evangelical Free Church of America in Stevens Point, several encounters occurred in Huffman’s office there, according to the complaint.
The boy told police he let Huffman do these things because Huffman was his mentor and because he was drunk or high, according to the complaint. When the boy got older, he told Huffman he didn’t want to have sexual contact with him anymore, and Huffman respected the request. About six months later, Huffman told the boy he no longer wanted to hang out with him, according to the complaint.
If convicted of the charges, Huffman faces a maximum of 221 years and 9 months in prison.
Huffman is now facing new accusations of sexual assault.
The OshKosh Northwestern reports:
A former Plover pastor accused of sexually assaulting a boy from his church beginning in 2017 was arrested May 19 and charged with sexually assaulting a 12-year-old boy in Winnebago County.
Jordan Huffman, 52, of Oshkosh, faces charges of first-degree sexual assault of a child under age 13, child enticement for sexual contact, and three counts of felony bail jumping.
Shortly after 1 a.m. May 19, a 12-year-old boy called 911 and told Winnebago County dispatch he had been kidnapped from an address in Appleton, was in a vehicle and the man who took him was “coming back,” according to a criminal complaint.
Dispatchers tracked GPS location from the juvenile’s cellphone and sent officers to the Econo Lodge Hotel at 2000 Holly Road in Fox Crossing, according to police.
Police conducted a traffic stop on Huffman’s vehicle, and the boy ran out of the vehicle “screaming and crying,” according to the complaint. Police took Huffman into custody.
In an interview with investigators at the Fox Valley Child Advocacy Center, the boy said he received and accepted a Snapchat friend request sometime between 11 p.m. and midnight May 18. He engaged in conversation with the other Snapchat user, during which he informed the person he was 12 years old. The person sent a nude photo, and the boy said he sent one back that he found online.
The boy said the Snapchat user stopped sending messages for a bit, then asked if the boy wanted to talk on the phone. The boy said no, and within minutes, he received a message saying “I’m here,” according to the complaint. The man was in a vehicle outside the boy’s house.
The boy said he “was confused and didn’t know how the male knew where he lived,” then realized his Snapchat location settings were on, the complaint says. He told investigators he went into the man’s vehicle, thinking they were only going to talk, then the man began driving and told the boy they were going to a hotel.
When they arrived at the hotel, the man took the car keys and checked in, leaving the boy in the car. The boy said this was when he called the police.
When the man returned, the boy said, they went into the hotel and sexual contact occurred. The boy said he faked a phone call from his mother, and told the man his mom was calling to tell him to come home. He said he called police again, pretending it was his mom, according to the complaint.
The boy said the man was beginning to take the boy back to his house when the police arrived. The boy said Huffman asked if he had “set him up,” according to the complaint.
Huffman has an open case in Portage County for which he faces one count of first-degree sexual assault of a child under 13, two counts of repeated sexual assault of the same child, three counts of child enticement for sexual contact, one count of causing a child to view sexual activity and one count of contributing to the delinquency of a child.
In that case, Huffman is accused of engaging in sexual activity with an adolescent boy he met through church over the course of multiple years.
According to a criminal complaint for the Portage County case, in 2017 a couple approached Huffman, then a pastor at Woodlands Church in Plover, and asked him to mentor their 12-year-old son who had been drinking and getting in trouble. The boy told police Huffman did not help him, but instead gave him alcohol, marijuana and prescription pills, and engaged in sexual contact with the boy.
The boy told police that Huffman on multiple occasions gave him alcohol, marijuana or pills, and while the boy was under the influence, Huffman would drive him to a remote location and inappropriately touch him with his mouth or hands. In one instance, the boy said Huffman sexually assaulted him in Huffman’s house while his wife and children were gone.
The first incident occurred when the boy was 12, and continued for a couple years, the boy said. When the boy was 15, he said he told Huffman he no longer wanted to engage in sexual contact. He said he and Huffman continued to hang out for about six months before Huffman told the boy he no longer wanted to spend time with him, the complaint says.
The Portage County charges were filed in August, after the victim came forward with information.
On June 23, 2023, Huffman pleaded guilty to two felony counts of repeated sexual assault of the same child.
A former Plover youth minister pleaded guilty Friday morning in Portage County Circuit Court to two felony counts of repeated sexual assault of the same child.
Portage County Circuit Court Judge Michael Zell ordered a pre-sentence investigation for Jordan R. Huffman, 52, who currently is in the Winnebago County Jail on a $1 million bail for unrelated charges of first-degree sexual assault of a child, child enticement and three counts of felony bail jumping.
Zell scheduled a sentencing hearing for Oct. 3.
As part of a plea agreement in the Portage County case, a charge of first-degree sexual assault of a child under age 13 was dismissed. Three charges of child enticement, a charge of causing a child age 13 to 18 to view sexual activity and a charge of contributing to the delinquency of a child were dismissed but read into the record.
According to the criminal complaint, in 2017 a couple approached Huffman, who at the time was a pastor at Woodlands Church in Plover, and asked him to mentor their 12-year-old son. The boy had started drinking and getting into trouble.
The boy told police instead of helping him, Huffman did the opposite. Huffman gave the boy alcohol, marijuana and prescription pills, according to the complaint. The child said Huffman would drive him to a remote location at the end of a dirt road after the boy was drunk or under the influence of marijuana and inappropriately touched him with his mouth or hands.
The boy said the encounters happened multiple times but no incident happened at Woodlands Church, other than Huffman telling the child he had alcohol, marijuana or nicotine cartridges for him, according to the complaint. He said Huffman had sexual intercourse with him one time at Huffman’s home while his wife and children were gone.
When Huffman left Woodlands Church and took a job with Forest Lakes District Evangelical Free Church of America in Stevens Point, several encounters occurred in Huffman’s office there, according to the complaint. The assaults lasted about five years.
The boy told police he let Huffman do these things because the pastor was his mentor and because he was drunk or high. When the boy was 17, he told Huffman he didn’t want to have sexual contact with him anymore, and Huffman respected the request, according to the complaint. About six months later, Huffman told the boy he no longer wanted to hang out with him.
Bruce Gerencser, 67, lives in rural Northwest Ohio with his wife of 46 years. He and his wife have six grown children and sixteen grandchildren. Bruce pastored Evangelical churches for twenty-five years in Ohio, Texas, and Michigan. Bruce left the ministry in 2005, and in 2008 he left Christianity. Bruce is now a humanist and an atheist.
Your comments are welcome and appreciated. All first-time comments are moderated. Please read the commenting rules before commenting.
You can email Bruce via the Contact Form.
