I am sixty-six years old. I spent fifty years in the Evangelical church. I pastored Evangelical churches in Ohio, Texas, and Michigan for twenty-five years. I have spent the last decade writing about Evangelicalism. You would think, by now, that there is nothing Evangelicals could say or do that I have not heard or seen before. Surely, Solomon was right when he said, “there’s nothing new under the sun.” Well, Solly boy, you are wrong.
Several years ago, Evangelical author and preacher Randy Alcorn decided to answer a question about animals in Heaven. Evidently, more than a few Evangelicals are stressed out over whether Rover or Fido will go to God’s Heavenly Trump Hotel® when they die. Here’s what Alcorn had to say:
Look at Genesis 1 and 2, and the highlight of all creation built up to is people. But right before people came animals. Those living beings, the first living beings that God made, animals. And it’s magnificent and wondrous that the first responsibility God gave to human beings along with to be fruitful and multiply and fill the Earth was to manage and care for animals. Adam named the animals. With the Flood, God makes a covenant not only with people but with animals. This is stated again and again in Genesis 6 through 9 and the Flood account. What we find in Isaiah 65 is the wolf and the lamb—and he specifically calls this the New Earth, so this is not just the Millennium. This is the New Earth. In verse 25 of Isaiah 65, ‘the wolf and the lamb shall graze together, the lion will eat straw like the ox,’ and then in Isaiah 11, it’s got leopard, goat, calf, cow, bear, ox, lion, cobra. When God remakes the earth, why would he not remake it with animals? Well, we know He will for sure because of these passages that have animals on the new earth, but also because Romans 8 says the entire creation has fallen. Creation fell on the coattails of human beings. So animals suffer death because humans sinned, and humans suffer death. But it says in that passage that not just human beings but the entire creation—well then, who does that leave that has suffered on this earth? Animals will experience the resurrection of the sons of God. So since some animals who have suffered [and who are] alive in this lifetime on this fallen earth will … be raised, which animals will those be? I think the most logical answer to that would be—and wouldn’t it be just like a loving God to do this for His children—that He will bring back those precious pets that He has entrusted to our care. We have a golden retriever named Maggie, we had a dalmatian named Moses, [and] we had a springer spaniel before that named Champ. Those dogs are very real to me and I anticipate actual reunion with them in heaven. By the way, I didn’t use to believe that, until I spent those two or three [years] studying Scripture intently every day on that subject. The Bible changed my mind on that subject.
NOW I have heard everything!
First, Alcorn spent two or three years studying this issue? Really? Surely, he using hyperbole (or lying). How long can it take to read and study the relevant passages of Scripture? Not long, surely no longer than an afternoon in the study with a Bible and a good bottle of scotch. I suspect that Alcorn wants people to know that he really, really, really studied this issue before he opened his mouth and added to the canon of nonsense for which Evangelicals are known.
Second, one of the biggest weapons atheists have in their arsenal is the fact that the Christian God allows innocent animals to suffer. Unlike humans who are sinners, animals stand blameless before God — except when they pee on God’s white shag carpet. The sheer violence and brutality in the animal kingdom are sure signs that either the Christian God is a psychopath who gets off on suffering, is indifferent towards suffering, or doesn’t exist. I will take door number three.
Alcorn likely thinks that he is somewhat answering this challenge by saying that “some” animals will go to Heaven after they die. Animals aren’t sinners, nor can they repent and ask Jesus into their heart, so why does Alcorn assert that only “some” animals” will make it through the Pearly Gates? Simply put, Alcorn believes that only animals (pets) owned by Christians will inherit the Kingdom of God. In Alcorn’s mind, God is an awesome dude. He loves his bleating sheep so much that he would never eternally separate them from their pets. Alcorn leaves unsaid the flip side of his argument: that the pets of unsaved people will go to Hell when they die. You can’t have Heaven without Hell, right? Or so Evangelicals have been saying f-o-r-e-v-e-r.
Imagine being a dog or cat at the local animal shelter. You want to go to a good home, to be adopted by a loving, caring family. But now you have to worry about your prospective family’s religious beliefs. Choose wrong and you will be an eternal hotdog on a stick. Choose right and you will never have poop in an uncleaned cat box again.
Third, Alcorn doesn’t mention non-dog pets. Will Christian-owned snakes, pot-belly pigs, hamsters, gerbils, cats, horses, raccoons, squirrels, birds, lizards, and fish go to Heaven when they die? Or do Calvin’s doctrines of election and predestination apply to pets too; that only dogs chosen from before the foundation of the world will be saved from the wrath to come?
So many questions . . .
I can imagine Evangelical churches starting pet-centric evangelistic ministries.
Deacon Bob and Preacher Billy are out and about in the community knocking on doors. They come upon the home of an atheist who just so happens to own 666 dogs.
Knock Knock
The atheist cracks the door open, holding back with his foot numerous dogs who want to escape or hump Preacher Billy’s leg.
Atheist: Can I help you?
Preacher Billy: Hello, my name is Billy, and this is Bob. We are in your neighborhood today knocking on doors. We would like to share the good news of the gospel with you and your dogs.
Atheist: My dogs? (saying to himself, these nutters are crazier than the Jehovah’s Witnesses)
Deacon Bob: Yes, after three years of intensive Bible study, we have learned that dogs too can go to Heaven when they die!
Atheist: Really? (saying to himself, these two guys have brain damage)
Preacher Billy: Yep. According to God’s inspired, inerrant, infallible Word, some dogs go to Heaven when they die!
Atheist: Some?
Preacher Billy: Yes. Their salvation is contingent on their owner being a Christian. If their owner is, uh, you know, an atheist like you, they will go to Hell when they die. Surely, you want your dogs to run the golden streets of the New Jerusalem for eternity, right? Please, Mr. Atheist, ask Jesus to save you.
Just pray this prayer: Dear Baby Jesus, I know I am a sinner. I know you died on the cross to save me and my dogs. I ask you to come into my heart right now and save me, and take me and my dogs to Heaven when we die! In Jesus’ name, Amen.
Atheist: Sorry, Dude, but there’s no God, no Heaven, no Hell. When my dogs die, I put them in a hole in my backyard. End of story.
Deacon Bob: Blasphemy! (Holding up an oversized rawhide bone) Come out from him, Satan!
The atheist derisively laughs, opens the door, and turns 666 dogs on Preacher Billy and Deacon Bob. These men of God flee into the night, shouting, “Someday you’ll be burning in Hell with all your dogs! And then you will know we were right!”
The next day Preacher Billy and Deacon Bob are nowhere to be found. Late that day, the local newspaper reports that the two were chased by a horde of demon-possessed dogs and plunged over a cliff to their deaths (much like the Bible story about the Maniac of Gadera).
Moral of the story: beware of atheists and their dogs. 🙂
Bruce Gerencser, 67, lives in rural Northwest Ohio with his wife of 46 years. He and his wife have six grown children and thirteen grandchildren. Bruce pastored Evangelical churches for twenty-five years in Ohio, Texas, and Michigan. Bruce left the ministry in 2005, and in 2008 he left Christianity. Bruce is now a humanist and an atheist.
Connect with me on social media:
Your comments are welcome and appreciated. All first-time comments are moderated. Please read the commenting rules before commenting.
You can email Bruce via the Contact Form.
A very funny post, Bruce which made me LOL over my first caffeine fix of the day! This tortuous explanation of scripture is just the latest example to me of how incomprehensible it is that an omnipotent god didn’t make his instruction book for the whole of humanity clearer. Bear of little brain that I am, I think I could have made a better job of writing the manual. I’m adding this word salad about pets and the pearly gates to other recent nonsensical sermons I’ve heard. Viz: when breasts are mentioned in Song of Solomon, the right one is the OT and the left one is the NT. Then I heard that the raising of Lazarus was important as Bethany was a leper colony, so, unusually, his sisters were heads of their household so had no other male relative to go to jesus to ask for help. Another preacher said being veggie is sinful cos god gave us animals to kill and eat. I still haven’t worked out the word salad I heard about the verse in Thessalonians about the jews killing jesus, Paul’s not anti-semitic, oh no, definitely not, oh no, we must never think that….yadda, yadda, yadda! Isn’t god up there on his throne doing a face palm at all the centuries of sheer nonsense spewed out so often by the leaders of his sheeple? Apparently not as it just keeps on coming.
In heaven there will be dogs? And lions, and tigers and bears? Oh my!
And jellyfish and sunflowers? After all, sunflowers move to face the sun. If they move and block out one of God’s other flowers from receiving light, are they eternal toast?
Should it be that I actually have a soul that survives death, that soul won’t be able to do much, for it won’t have a brain. See https://mindsetfree.blog/if-only-souls-had-a-brain/ .
So animals suffer because humans sinned. Once again the inconvenient question of dinosaurs comes into play. If there were no sinful humans around yet who is to blame for the suffering and death of the billions of these creatures? I’m sure this nutcase would argue that dinosaurs were not prehistoric but created with the rest of the animals in the garden of Eden. I suppose if Adam and Eve had a pet brontosaurus we would expect to see it in heaven playing with all the Christian cats, dogs and goldfish. ( When I say we I don’t mean me since I will be in hell with the atheist animals and Bruce)
So does this Alcorn say that pets in general,who don’t have Christian owners are in danger of going to Hell now ? Or is this just tongue in cheek. A guess on his part ? Animals aren’t under any condemnation, because they don’t comprehend sin anyway, correct ? They can’t be judged for sin. Sure they can reason up to a point, but that’s limited.
“…Alcorn doesn’t mention non-dog pets. Will Christian-owned snakes, pot-belly pigs, hamsters, gerbils, cats, horses, raccoons, squirrels, birds, lizards, and fish go to Heaven when they die?”
Oh dear. If Alcorn reads this, it could prompt him to go on another 2-3 year intense scripture study quest, when he could instead spend all that time focusing on the sick and the poor… people.
So only some dogs go to heaven through some sort of surrogate salvation scheme? Huh.
So,wait…..Calvinism applies to dogs? Wow. What about Arminians? Can their dogs backslide?? Wait, what happens if the dog’s owner backslides,,.can the dog still be saved?
So many questions.
Saint Peter: “Sorry for the racket… there are billions of dogs up here, and they get a little excited when someone’s at the gate.”
Need a little humor this morning? See https://www.cartoonstock.com/directory/d/dog_heaven.asp .
Actually, the notion that whether or not Fido or Felix go to Heaven is contingent on their human’s salvation, or lack thereof, is completely consistent with everything that Evangelicals believe about God. After all, said deity condemns people for things they didn’t even know about.
Honestly, though, if there is a Heaven populated by animals (except ferrets), I just might start believing. I would rather spend eternity with them than with most people who are supposedly going to their “Eternal Reward.”
“Their salvation is contingent on their owner being a Christian. If their owner is, uh, you know, an atheist like you, they will go to Hell when they die. ”
Ha ha ha ha ha~ Fuck you, man! Fuck you!
Seriously though, if someone proselytyse this way to me, I would clobber them. That’s so fucking offensive
Your are so right, I.I. Me, I never had anyone say that pets of non- believers go to hell. They don’t know what the concept of ” sin” is anyway. Heaven help any dolt stupid enough to say such a thing to me !!😿🐕🐰