The Black Collar Crime Series relies on public news stories and publicly available information for its content. If any incorrect information is found, please contact Bruce Gerencser. Nothing in this post should be construed as an accusation of guilt. Those accused of crimes are innocent until proven guilty.
In 2018, Gary Miller, pastor of Sycamore Baptist Church in Springfield, Missouri (the church is permanently closed), was accused of raping a female church member. Previously, Miller had been investigated on child abuse allegations, but never charged.
According to the Springfield News-Leader:
Officials say a Springfield man accused of using an elaborate scheme to extort and rape a woman was a pastor.
And a former churchgoer says the pastor admitted at least parts of the act to his congregation six years ago.
Gary Miller, 41, was charged Tuesday with forcible rape and forcible sodomy following allegations that he sent “anonymous” threat letters to set up a sexual assault in 2012.
Sherry Clark said Miller was her pastor in 2012 at Sycamore Baptist Church in Springfield.
Clark said one day in 2012, Miller stood in front of the congregation and admitted to having sex with the victim.
Clark said she could not remember if Miller also admitted to other parts of the alleged scheme, like sending the threat letters.
“I was shocked because he’s got kids of his own,” Clark said. “He never seemed like he would be that type of guy.”
Clark said the day of Miller’s admissions was her last at Sycamore Baptist Church, and she assumed that Miller would soon face legal consequences.
Clark said she doesn’t understand why it took six years for charges to be filed in the case.
“Why they are just now opening up a case about it is insane to me,” Clark said.
Public court documents indicate police only recently became aware of the alleged rape scheme while they were investigating other sexual abuse allegations made against Miller.
According to a probable cause statement, a woman told police last week that in August 2012 she got a letter in the mail from an “anonymous” sender that threatened harm against her loved ones if she did not film herself having sex with Miller.
The statement says the woman confided in Miller about the letter, and he suggested they meet in person to discuss what to do.
Miller allegedly told the woman that he did not want to have sex with her, but he felt like they had no choice.
The statement says the woman first pushed Miller away but eventually gave in and had sex with Miller as he used his cellphone to film the encounter.
After the incident, the statement says Miller insisted on tucking the victim into bed and praying with her.
The statement says that last week Miller admitted to writing the letters and carrying out the scheme in a conversation with his wife.
In July 2019, Miller pleaded guilty to sexual assault and deviate sexual assault. He was later sentenced to seven years in prison.
The Springfield News-Reporter reported at the time:
A former Springfield pastor was sentenced Friday to 7 years in prison for orchestrating an elaborate plan to manipulate and sexually assault a woman.
Gary Miller, 42, was given the prison time after a hearing in front of Judge Ron Carrier.
A probable cause statement used to charge Miller last year says a woman told police that in August 2012 she got a letter in the mail from an “anonymous” sender that threatened harm against her loved ones if she did not film herself having sex with Miller.
The statement says the woman confided in Miller about the letter, and he suggested they meet in person to discuss what to do.
Miller allegedly told the woman that he did not want to have sex with her, but he felt like they had no choice.
….
The statement says the woman eventually agreed to have sex with Miller as he used his cell phone to film the encounter.
After the incident, the statement says Miller insisted on tucking the victim into bed and praying with her.
The statement says that in 2018 Miller admitted to orchestrating the scheme in a conversation with his then-wife.
Miller was initially charged with forcible rape and forcible sodomy, but he pleaded guilty in July to sexual assault and deviate sexual assault. The difference is significant since the maximum sentence for each charge dropped from life in prison to 7 years in prison.
Miller’s attorney Dean Price said the crime involved trickery, not physical force.
“There was never any force used,” Price said. “The charge was amended to reflect what actually happened.”
Bruce Gerencser, 67, lives in rural Northwest Ohio with his wife of 46 years. He and his wife have six grown children and thirteen grandchildren. Bruce pastored Evangelical churches for twenty-five years in Ohio, Texas, and Michigan. Bruce left the ministry in 2005, and in 2008 he left Christianity. Bruce is now a humanist and an atheist.
Connect with me on social media:
Your comments are welcome and appreciated. All first-time comments are moderated. Please read the commenting rules before commenting.
You can email Bruce via the Contact Form.
That’s such a disgusting crime.
It’s definitely disgusting, and just to note, this guy isn’t a drag queen, gay, or transgender. He fits the profile of the majority of sexual offenders being heterosexual males. I hope his church doesn’t try to rehabilitate him like David Hyles.
Miller looks like a violent guy. And if I read it right, he was investigated for beating children ? And those outlandish, clumsy lies he told the object of his stalker behavior to trick her into going to submit to his demand for sex,with him, then tucking her into bed and ” praying” with her ! Eww ! How on Earth did Miller think he could pray with/ for anyone at all ?? And expect an answer- unless it was getting arrested . That was the answer after all.😙👍
So he wanted to make potential revenge porn while raping a woman?
And he molested children?
Yulya–People pray after killing, raping or stealing. They think that no matter what they do, God is on their side.
Gary Miller was my youth pastor when I was a teenager.
I wanted to note if you look at his sex offender registry, the “woman” victim above was 17 at the time of this sexual assault.
He was recently released from the crimes discussed above and was arrested again for the following charges: STATUTORY SODOMY 1ST DEGREE DEVIATE SEXUAL INTERCOURSE WITH PERSON LESS THAN 14 YEARS OLD
SERIOUS PHYSICAL INJURY/DISPLAYS
DEADLY WEAPON OR DANGEROUS
INSTRUMENT/SUBJECTS VICTIM TO
INTERCOURSE WITH MORE THAN ONE
PERSON/VICTIM IS LESS THAN 12 YEARS
OF AGE.
These crimes occured while he was a youth pastor at Jefferson Avenue Baptist Church, the victim being a child in said church. It’s important to note the church knew about the former allegations while he was in this position and did not notify or alert families of said allegations. He had a known addiction to porn and discussed this openly with teenagers in church.
Gary Miller was also a foster parent (pretty sure with Missouri Baptist Children’s Home, as that’s what is listed on his wife’s Facebook page from 2006-present) and had several kids in his care during all of these continuous investigations.
It’s so heartbreaking to see how the church and government have failed so many children this man had access to.
Thank you for covering this story, it’s a shame this is more hidden in press and in the very communities directly affected by his actions.