No, John Sadak, Singing “God Bless America” at Baseball Games is Not a Sunday Tradition

john sadak god bless america

I am a diehard Cincinnati Reds fan. Come hell, high water, or a losing season, I watch or listen to every Reds game. Currently, John Sadak and Jeff “Cowboy” Brantley call most of the games on TV. Every Sunday fans are treated to the singing of God Bless America. I either mute or fast forward through the sound — a minor annoyance, to be sure, but an annoyance, nonetheless.

Today, Sadak called the singing of God Bless America a “Sunday Tradition,” to which I politely 🙂 replied bullshit! The singing of “God Bless America” is a post 9-11 innovation. This sound may have had a unifying effect twenty-five years ago, but today it is song glorifying militarism and imperialism; complete with military planes or helicopters flying overhead.

The same goes for unfurling a field-sized U.S. flag while a soloist or group belts out the un-singable war song, The Star Spangled Banner. More flyovers too, an ever-present witness to our military might. Little do younger adults know that there was a time when we didn’t worship nationalism and Christianity. Today, we wave the flag of American exceptionalism with nary a thought. Sadak furthers this narrative by implying that singing God Bless America during the seventh inning of Reds game is a Sunday tradition. It is not, and never has been. Singing “Take Me Out to the Ballgame” during the seventh inning six days a week . . . now that’s a baseball tradition.

When I turn on the Reds, I want to watch the game, not listen to masturbatory worship of American nationalism. Sadak might want to consider that many people in the stands and at home aren’t supporters of decades of military interventions and deaths across the globe; people who recognize the need for self-defense, but not wars over natural resources, communism, regime change, and geography; or even worse, wars fought solely based on lies

Count me as a patriotic Reds fan who wants military-free ballgames. I don’t believe for a moment that soldiers are dying in the Middle East so we can enjoy Sunday baseball games at home. Not in my name, I say. I don’t want one drop of innocent blood shed for the “American Dream”, another barrel of oil, or Donald Trump’s war fantasy.

Bruce Gerencser, 69, lives in rural Northwest Ohio with his wife of 48 years. He and his wife have six grown children and thirteen grandchildren. Bruce pastored Evangelical churches for twenty-five years in Ohio, Texas, and Michigan. Bruce left the ministry in 2005, and in 2008 he left Christianity. Bruce is now a humanist and an atheist.

Your comments are welcome and appreciated. All first-time comments are moderated. Please read the commenting rules before commenting.

You can email Bruce via the Contact Form.

Comments

11 responses to “No, John Sadak, Singing “God Bless America” at Baseball Games is Not a Sunday Tradition”

  1. Avatar
    John S.

    I’m with you, Bruce. I remember when it was just the Star Spangled Banner 🇺🇸. That’s it. Most everyone stood. Why? Because it was all of maybe 30-60 seconds. Then it was play ball!
    I don’t mind patriotism in (very) small doses. But making everyone stand through overly performative patriotism displays ironically is no different than what happens countries that we historically were/are “fighting”- the USSR (and now nationalist Russia), North Korea, China and Iran. All kinds of hyper (and mandatory) patriotic performances in those places. Why? So the local populace understands the heavy presence of the government.
    I remember when it really didn’t matter if you flew the flag on July 4th at your house. Most did but not all. Sometimes we did, sometimes not. 9-11 and the Iraq war was when I started to notice the whole “I’m more ‘Merican than you!” stuff- large American flag stickers on cars, hats, etc. It’s a free country (supposedly). Display that all you want. Just don’t expect me to follow suit. I can love the country but still detest the current government. My son is currently in the Army. I can support him and still disagree with this very stupid and wasteful war we are (trying to) wage against Iran (in order to help Netanyahu).
    Our professional sports should unite people. With the current war in Iran pollling at around 75% against, including a good portion of MAGA minded folks, I don’t think God Bless America, flyovers and large flags covering the field are appropriate or helpful.
    My concession would be the instrumental version of the Star Spangled Banner (more because it pisses off really religious people who call it a tavern song) over the loud speaker while a normal size flag is raised. Stand or sit as you wish. That’s it, then on to the game.

  2. Avatar

    Just wait till they find out “God Bless America” was written by a (((JEW)))!!!

  3. Troy

    I searched on “Take Me Out to the Ball Game”, you’re 100% correct! THAT is the 7th inning tradition.
    I hope you wrote the Reds a cordial snail mail telling them you’d prefer to bring back the original tradition. (I wouldn’t even mention the fact that many secular Americans would prefer not to have what is essentially a religious hymn)
    Whenever I hear “God Bless America” I always figure we sneezed… and I suppose Trump is the bloody glob of mucus running down our face.

  4. Avatar
    Jeff Bishop

    As a student of History I find Nationalism, Religious Fanaticism, Racism, to be diabolic concepts, fostered on those from their power positions upon youth (babies) born into their particular “ism” as a mind controlling, propagandist
    method of control. As if any human born ever had a “choice” about where that birth would be.

    God Bless America, Star Spangled Banner, and such may be meant to inspire cultists or citizens with patriotic fervor.
    For me, when I think about it, #1, God Bless America, I see the legacy of countless dead and dying at the hands of Christians. The annihilation of the real Americans, mainly by white skinned Aristocratic Europeans, come to rob, pillage, enslave and murder.

    #2 The Star Spangled Banner, brings to mind further indigenous annihilation, The Mexican American Conflict, The Civil War, The trepidation’s of the United Fruit Co in Central America, The overthrow of a Democracy in Iran, in 1953, courtesy of Churchill and Eisenhower, Vietnam, Afghanistan, and the recent Imperialistic moves in the middle east.

    Just sayin…………..

  5. Avatar

    As someone who doesn’t believe in deities, I despise “God Bless America”. And I haven’t figured out what to say in its place. I usually take that time to go to the bathroom if I’m at a live game.

  6. We used to sing “God Bless America” in school. I didn’t get it then. I don’t get it now.

    1. Avatar

      It’s a leftover from WWII, and it’s basically, “God, help us win this war.”
      Also, it was composed by Irving Berlin, who was… Jewish, but don’t tell these chowderheads that unless you want to see their heads asplode…

  7. Avatar
    matilddaa

    I can’t comment about US sports traditions, but here in the UK, my part of world is fanatical about welsh rugby and Liverpool (or rival Everton) soccer clubs. if you’re interested, look up Youtube videos of fans singing anthems at matches. The welsh love ‘Bread of Heaven,’ though I’m guessing only 1-2% go to church, it’s the harmonies that get you and welsh male-voice singing can be very moving and bring tears to the eyes. And every Liverpool fan can sing the words to ‘You’ll never walk alone.’ Anthems are cohesive to pack membership….but yuck to the religious ones…and what does ‘Godbles actually mean. We taught our small kids to pray, when fundy, and stopped them as the god-bless list got too long, every family member by name, friends and the rabbit next door, auntie’s old dog and the six sick kitties down the street whose mum couldn’t suckle them cos of her sore nipples!

  8. Avatar

    I thought I was the only one who hates the Star-Spangled Banner! America the Beautiful would be a much better national anthem, without glorification of war. Did you know this country has been at war for 232 years out of its 250 year existence?

    1. Avatar

      Yep. I will be 70 next year. The United States has been at war my entire life. We are bloody nation.

      I love to sing, even though preaching largely ruined my golden tenor voice (not my assessment, but that of others) over the years. I want a national anthem that’s singable by everyday people. There’s one thing I loved about IFB churches. The music tended to be uplifting and singable.

    2. Avatar
      John S.

      You know, upon further reflection I think you’re right. I often confuse America the Beautiful with God Bless America. But playing it in my head, America the Beautiful flows better than Star Spangled Banner, and is more uplifting.
      I do like the instrumental version of Star Spangled Banner but don’t care for the lyrics.
      I remember as a kid listening to the TV station sign offs late at night. Most of them played the instrumental version of Star Spangled Banner, except one. Cincinnati’s PBS station, channel. 48, played America the Beautiful. Another (I don’t remember) played a song whose refrain went, “This is My Country”, which sounded nice. Of course the Covington, KY KET/PBS channel played “My Old Kentucky Home”.
      I stand corrected from my first comment, although I’m not sure whether this nations sports fans would be willing to part with the Star Spangled Banner.

Want to Respond to Bruce? Fire Away! If You Are a First Time Commenter, Please Read the Comment Policy Located at the Top of the Page.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Discover more from The Life and Times of Bruce Gerencser

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading