The Life and Times of Bruce Gerencser

Luke Taylor is the pastor of Veneration Church, a Southern Baptist congregation in Kalispell, Montana. Taylor, a culture warrior, recently preached a sermon series titled Culture Clash: A Biblical Look at Culture’s Hottest Topics. Spanning five sermons so far, Taylor preached oh-so-important sermons such as: A Battle for the Heart, Sexual Purity, Transgenderism, Homosexuality, and Abortion. The sermon videos had subtitles such as:

• There has been a major clash between culture and biblical truth. Paul warns the church not to be deceived as the unrighteous will not inherit the Kingdom of God. A battle has been waged for the heart, and the only remedy is Jesus and a complete surrender to Him.
• If sex is like a consuming fire, why has God commanded us to control the burn? We know His command for purity is all over the Bible, but what is the reason for this command? How is it for our best? How has the devil hijacked God’s plan for sex, and kept us from enjoying the most satisfying and fulfilling sex you can imagine? As we will see, God invented sex for our good and His glory, and His plan is the best and most satisfying by design. Nothing else can compare.
• At the core of the LGBTQ community rests two common traits: a rebellion against God and a personal brokenness that leads to a search for identity. Transgenderism is the fruit of rebellion and brokenness. How does the Bible speak to these issues and how is the church to respond?
• At the core of the LGBTQ+ community rests two common traits: a rebellion against God and His design and a personal brokenness that is in search of healing. What does the Bible say about homosexuality and same-sex marriage? Why are these against God’s design and how do we know? How do you wrestle with these issues in light of the Gospel and salvation? How is the church to respond? 
• Statistics would show that over 40% of women, both inside and outside the church, have been touched by the pain of abortion. For every woman that has walked this road, there is also a man. While the Bible has much to say about the sanctity of life, it also has much to say about the forgiveness the cross of Christ offers for any who have walked down this painful road. To think that any sin cannot be forgiven by the blood of Jesus is to cheapen the cross of Christ. God not only forgives, but He also restores and redeems.

Taylor didn’t announce his sermon titles in advance, fearing congregants would skip church if they knew he was preaching about their particular sin. The Sunday he planned to preach on abortion, this is what happened:

Taylor did not announce the sermon schedule because he didn’t want people to choose which sermons they might avoid. However, he accidentally mentioned when he would preach on abortion. “Driving home after church, I felt the Spirit of God telling me to switch the weekends for this topic because there might be women who would skip that sermon due to the grips of guilt and shame.”

Sure enough, Taylor heard that some women planned to miss that sermon. “If God was going to set them free, they needed to be there,” he said. So Taylor changed plans. The result was that “many women showed up the following weekend and were set free. God did God things in God ways,” Taylor said.

Taylor was recently interviewed by The Baptist Paper about his sermon series. Taylor assured readers that his sermons were not political; that if someone took issue with his sermons, their problem was with God, not him.

Taylor stated:

[The series was] “not about what we are standing against but about who we are standing for. [Drawing from biblical teachings, Taylor prayed for the sermons to be] presented in a way that if anyone had a problem with what I said it would be because they rebelled against God’s Word and not my opinion.

Nothing like a cocksure Baptist preacher, right? Certain that his personal interpretations of the Bible are straight from the mouth of God, Taylor viewed any objections to his sermons as rebellion against the inerrant, infallible Word of God.

I was an Evangelical preacher for twenty-five years. According to church members and colleagues in the ministry, my sermons were well crafted and used by God to bring conviction of sin and salvation. When asked about my sermons, my partner of forty-six years, Polly — who heard virtually every one of my 4,000+ sermons — always voiced approbation for my messages. Even when I missed the mark with a sermon, Polly always praised me for a good job. Awesome wife, right? 🙂 I learned not to trust her judgments of my sermons, knowing her love for me was greater than the quality of a particular sermon. Some church members did the same as they shook my hand after church, saying, “Preacher, that was a wonderful sermon.” The subject matter didn’t matter, my sermons were always supercalifragilisticexpialidocious. The judgments of my sermons that did matter to me were the ones from my fellow preachers. By all accounts, my sermons were well received by them.

I took the craft of preaching seriously. I learned early on that sermons could be used to “motivate” people to behave in certain ways. Choose the right text, use timely heart-tugging illustrations, and deliver the sermon with passion and conviction, it was not hard to get people to make decisions for Christ. While I had sincere intentions, desiring, as Taylor does, to save sinners and bring conviction of sin to church members, I eventually recognized that what I was really doing was psychologically manipulating people. Eventually, I stopped giving altar calls and dialed back aspects of my preaching I felt were manipulative. Preaching expositional sermons instead of topical/textual sermons helped limit the kind of manipulation found in Taylor’s Culture Clash sermon series. My goal was to teach the Bible and let congregants do with it what they will.

I am not suggesting that Taylor is evil or a cult leader. Many preachers are unaware of how their sermons can be used to psychologically manipulate people, thinking that when people positively respond to their sermons by getting saved or confessing secret, long-held sin, it is the Holy Spirit moving instead of manipulation. For those of us raised in Baptist churches, we were indoctrinated and conditioned to respond to sermons in general, and certain content in particular, to make decisions for Christ. Sermon-induced guilt is labeled Holy Ghost conviction instead of what it is, psychological manipulation. I listened to several of Taylor’s sermons, particularly his sermon on Transgenderism. Taylor is well-spoken and knows how to use a well-turned phrase to elicit the desired response. His sermons conclude with a prayer, complete with background music. Then the church band starts playing. I assume this is Veneration Church’s version of an altar call. I have written previously about how Evangelical preachers use music to tug at the heartstrings (minds) of congregants, making it easier for them to get right with God. Whether it is the singing of Just As I Am or modern contemporary songs, the goal is to stir the passions of those in attendance.

Taylor’s certainly had the desired effect. Scores of church members confessed long-buried sins, including sexual sins. To give readers a good idea of what happened at Veneration Church, what follows is a video Taylor played for the congregation featuring his fellow pastor Tyler Wilschetz and his wife Alicia.

Video Link

Guilt is common among Evangelicals. When the focus is on sin — as defined by the pastor’s personal interpretations of the Bible — and brokenness, it is not surprising that church members feel so guilty. Guilt, then, becomes the fertile ground preachers use to encourage people to repent of secret sins and get right with God. Taylor told congregants that “guilt and shame” were from the Devil, but I suggest that they are the fruit of Evangelical dogma and psychological manipulation.

The Baptist Paper story gave several examples of how Taylor’s sermons affected church members:

One of Taylor’s sermons focused on sexual purity especially within the context of biblical marriage, citing premarital cohabitation, premarital sex, extramarital sex, and viewing porn as among numerous biblical prohibitions regarding sensuality.

“But why does the Bible speak so much about sexual purity?” he asked. Because only within God’s design is found “our full satisfaction, our complete enjoyment, and our greatest pleasure.”

For those who sorrow over previous sexual sins, Taylor said, “Guilt and shame are from the devil. But conviction comes from the Holy Spirit.” The power of the gospel redeems and frees us from the prison of past failures regardless of what they were, he said.

Following the sermon, Taylor’s invitation calling all who wanted to repent of sin and to commit to a life of purity garnered about 90 men who walked the aisle and stood up front in public testimony of their commitment.

….

One woman found freedom from decades of abortion guilt. She believed that her daughter — who was born without a right hand and died in her early thirties — was God’s judgment. She assessed the untimely death of her husband similarly.

In a subsequent discipleship group the walls fell.

The group leader reported to Taylor: “The woman let go of 40 years of guilt and pain. We had an incredible time of prayer over her, where she was able to grieve her baby, give up to God the falsehoods Satan had over her, and start her restoration of moving forward without guilt.”

Sadly, many of the “sins” Evangelicals feel guilty about are normal human behaviors. Notice Taylor’s obsession over sexual “sin.” Want to elicit guilt from church members? Preach on sexual behaviors deemed sinful by the churches/pastors. Sex is a basic human need, right up there with eating and drinking. I came of age in the Independent Fundamentalist Baptist church movement. I heard countless sermons about heinous sins such as premarital sex, fornication, lust, masturbation, and pornography. Instead of being taught to own my sexuality and learning how to act responsibly around the opposite sex, I learned that normal, healthy sexual desire was sin; that God would harshly judge me if I didn’t keep my pants zipped up and my mind focused on the precious Word of God. Try as I might, and no matter how many prayers I prayed, sermons I listened to, and Bible verses I read, I still had raging hormones. While both Polly and I were virgins on our wedding day, this was not because we conquered our sexual desires. No, we feared God would get us if we rounded third and slid into home. Many of our fellow youth group members and college friends were not as holy as we were. When the Devil rang the proverbial doorbell they answered the door, and the result was years of guilt over not adhering to the church’s Puritannical moral code. Some of my fellow dorm dwellers who succumbed to “lust” went on to pastor Baptist churches. A funny thing happened on their way to the pulpit. They forgot that they had hit home runs while at Midwestern Baptist College. Sexual “sins” long since confessed and buried were forgotten as they stood in their pulpits and arranged another generation of young people about the evils of handholding, kissing, petting, mutual sexual stimulation, fornication, and masturbation.

Teenagers and young adults are going to engage in sexual activity regardless of what they hear from the pulpit. Instead of preaching guilt-inducing sermons and telling young people to “just say no,” it would be better if pastors taught their young charges personal accountability and responsibility. Perhaps it is time to chuck the Bible and encourage young and old alike healthy attitudes about sex and desire. If Taylor’s sermon series should have taught him anything, it is that sermons such as his don’t bring lasting change. The Bible is no match for sexual want, need, and desire — as adult church members would affirm if they ever shared their sexual secrets. Imagine a church testimony time where one adult after another shared stories about hot summer nights and youthful desires. 🙂

Bruce Gerencser, 67, lives in rural Northwest Ohio with his wife of 46 years. He and his wife have six grown children and sixteen grandchildren. Bruce pastored Evangelical churches for twenty-five years in Ohio, Texas, and Michigan. Bruce left the ministry in 2005, and in 2008 he left Christianity. Bruce is now a humanist and an atheist.

Your comments are welcome and appreciated. All first-time comments are moderated. Please read the commenting rules before commenting.

You can email Bruce via the Contact Form.