
I listen to a plethora of YouTube channels, particularly call-in shows whose hosts attempt to engage and debate Evangelicals, Catholics, Muslims, and Jews. Evangelicals, in particular, often appeal to “divine command theory” to justify their God’s behavior.
The Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy defines divine command theory as:
the view that morality is somehow dependent upon God, and that moral obligation consists in obedience to God’s commands.
In other words, whatever God does is right. And I mean whatever . . . I have listened to countless Evangelicals defend everything from owning people as property (slavery) to rape to genocide. From philosophical arguments to appeals to the supremacy of “God’s ways,” God is vociferously defended by Evangelical apologists. No quarter is given. God’s holy name must be defended at all costs. And defend it they do, with justifications, excuses, and bizarre interpretations.
Underlying the notion of divine command theory is the claim that God is ALWAYS good; that whatever God does is, without exception, good. This means that when God ordered the genocide of the Amalekite people, it was a moral, just, and good command. When God ordered the slaughter of infants, no fault can be found in what followed.
Sensitive to being accused of promoting and justifying genocide, Evangelicals often cook up all sorts of explanations that allegedly protect God’s name against accusations of immorality. “God knew all those babies were going to go to Heaven anyway, so babies having their heads dashed upon the rocks is “good.” Of course, this means Evangelicals should be pro-abortion, killing fetuses before they are old enough to know the difference between right and wrong. Most Evangelicals believe fetuses and babies go to Heaven when they die. so it stands to reason that abortion (or slaughter by the Jews) is good as the result is eternity in Heaven. In other words, the end justifies the means. Wait a minute, I thought Evangelicals oppose situational ethics? Oh that’s what they say, but when defending God, absolute morality becomes an ever-moving target. The Ten Commandments say “Thou shalt not kill (murder).” Yet, it seems that when God is doing the killing, the supposedly “moral law of God” is massaged or ignored. Just remember, God’s ways are not our ways. In the minds of Evangelicals, whatever God does is moral and right, even when it seems that what he is doing is immoral. Just because rape, slavery, genocide, and murder are “sins” to fallen sinners, it doesn’t follow that those same acts committed by God are just, moral, and right. The Evangelical deity is never held accountable for his actions. How can mere mortals judge God? Evangelicals say, carving out an exception for God. This means that despite claims of having objective morals, Evangelicals, as do all of us, actually have subjective morals
Most Evangelicals believe the Bible was written by God, inerrant and infallible in all it says. This core belief forces Evangelicals to commit to defending the Bible regardless of what it says. No evil is beyond justification if God did it. Remember, this is the same God who created Hell/Lake of Fire, the final resting place for all non-Evangelicals. As eternity rolls on, unbelievers will be tortured by God for one simple reason: they didn’t believe in Jesus.
Here’s the thing, belief isn’t a choice. Either you believe or you don’t. We cannot genuinely believe if we are not convinced that a claim is true (I speak generally). Yes, this is a complex issue, especially when you consider human free will. Do we have free will? I’m inclined to think that we don’t; that our lives give the appearance of free will without actually being “free.” The notion that we have libertarian free will cannot be rationally sustained, though I am sure that some commenters want to disabuse me of this notion.
The Christian God is neither just, moral, nor good. I have seen no evidence in the Bible that would suggest I am wrong. If you disagree with me, please defend your God or divine command theory in the comment section. I await your defense of a “good” God.
Bruce Gerencser, 69, lives in rural Northwest Ohio with his wife of 48 years. He and his wife have six grown children and thirteen grandchildren. Bruce pastored Evangelical churches for twenty-five years in Ohio, Texas, and Michigan. Bruce left the ministry in 2005, and in 2008 he left Christianity. Bruce is now a humanist and an atheist.
Your comments are welcome and appreciated. All first-time comments are moderated. Please read the commenting rules before commenting.
You can email Bruce via the Contact Form.











