In the post that follows, I deliberately paint with a broad brush. If what I write doesn’t apply to your church or your pastor, then feel free to ignore my words.
The Independent Fundamentalist Baptist (IFB) church movement is a collection of thousands of churches that are independent denominationally, fundamentalist (Evangelical) in doctrine, and adhere to Baptist ecclesiology. (Please see Are Evangelicals Fundamentalists?) Under this large tent are churches that voluntarily associate with one another, often gathering around a particular Fundamentalist college (i.e. Bob Jones University, Pensacola Christian College, The Crown College, Midwestern Baptist College, Massillon Baptist College, Maranatha Baptist University, Hyles-Anderson College, Baptist Bible College) or specific geographical locations (please see Let’s Go Camping: Understanding Independent Fundamentalist Baptist Camps). Virulently anti-denominational, IFB churches/pastors pride themselves in being answerable only to God.
Answerable to no one but God — who never says a word to them — IFB churches are often controlled by authoritarian pastors who rule their churches with a rod of iron. Believing that they are divinely called to be pastors and commanded in Scripture to rule over their churches, these so-called men of God far too often become a law unto themselves. Their churches become their possessions, their ministries given to them by God to lead, direct, and control. It is not uncommon, much as in the business world, for IFB pastors to be the CEOs of their churches for decades, and when they retire, to pass their kingdoms on to their sons. Their churches become the family business. Ask IFB congregants where they attend church and they will often reply, not First Baptist Church, but Pastor or Bro. Johnny B. Awesome’s church. IFB churches are pastor-centric. Everything revolves around the pastor and his decrees.
The church culture described above is a perfect medium for sexual abuse, sexual misconduct, and other predatory behavior. There’s little to no accountability to anyone except God, and I can safely say that he hasn’t been seen in IFB churches in a long, long time. While an IFB pastor is answerable to his church’s membership, practically speaking, unless he steals money from the church, is caught fucking the deacon’s wife in his study, or some other egregious “sin,” he is pretty much safe from being fired. Over time, such men gain more and more power, so much so that it becomes almost impossible for congregants to get rid of them. I have seen church constitutions — often written by the pastors themselves — that require a seventy-five percent “yes” vote to remove the pastor.
IFB church members are often taught to implicitly trust their pastors and ignore any rumors they might hear about them. (Please see Sexual Abuse and the Jack Hyles Rule: If You Didn’t See It, It Didn’t Happen.) Rumors swirled around Jack and David Hyles for years, yet because church members were taught (indoctrinated and conditioned) to “trust and ignore,” the Hyleses escaped being held accountable for their abhorrent criminal behavior. Yes, I said “criminal.” It is clear from the latest Fort Worth Star-Telegram report on sexual abuse in IFB churches that David Hyles committed sex crimes and his father covered them up. This story has been repeated in numerous IFB churches over the years. Don’t think for a moment that the latest report on sexual abuse is new. This kind of behavior has been going on ever since I was a teenager at Trinity Baptist Church in Findlay, Ohio, five decades ago. It was covered up back then, and it is covered up today.
Sexual assaults, rapes, predatory behavior, and adultery are covered up way too often in IFB churches. Protecting the “good” name of the church in the community becomes more important than rooting out predatory behavior. Far too often, victims are either not believed or are blamed for what happened to them. IFB pastors are known for their sermons about how women dress, and how inappropriately dressed women are culpable for how poor, hapless, weak Baptist men respond to their carnal displays of flesh. Women (and teen girls) are expected to be gatekeepers; to dress and act in ways that keep church men and teen boys from having lustful thoughts about them. When Jack Schaap, the former pastor of First Baptist Church in Hammond, Indiana and Jack Hyles’ son-in-law, was arrested for sexually assaulting a church teenager he was counseling, more than a few Schaap defenders came to this site and blamed the girl for seducing him. She was called a slut, a whore, and a Jezebel. Schaap was viewed as a tired, overworked man of God who was an easy mark. Never mind the fact that Schaap was old enough to be the girl’s father and that he, through letters, cards, and text messages, sexually manipulated this help-seeking, vulnerable, naive girl. His disgraceful fall into sin was all her fault, according to his defenders.
The title of this post asks, What Will the IFB Church Movement Do About Sexual Abuse Allegations? The answer should be clear to all who are reading: NOTHING! As long as IFB churches remain independent and accountable to no one but the silent God, sexual abuse will continue. As long as congregants are taught to revere, fear, and unconditionally obey their pastors, it is unlikely that predatory IFB preachers will be in danger of exposure or criminal prosecution. As long as IFB preachers continue to promote warped views of human sexuality and sexual accountability, it is doubtful that predators and abusers will be held accountable for their crimes. And as long as churches value their own reputations more than the innocence of their children and the vulnerability of their women, pastors will continue their wicked ways.
Bruce Gerencser, 67, lives in rural Northwest Ohio with his wife of 46 years. He and his wife have six grown children and sixteen grandchildren. Bruce pastored Evangelical churches for twenty-five years in Ohio, Texas, and Michigan. Bruce left the ministry in 2005, and in 2008 he left Christianity. Bruce is now a humanist and an atheist.
Your comments are welcome and appreciated. All first-time comments are moderated. Please read the commenting rules before commenting.
You can email Bruce via the Contact Form.
But Bruce, it’s that icky gay sex that is consensual that is wrong, even if both partners are in a committed, loving relationship. But fundie Christians don’t care about consensual sex, they only consider heterosexual sex okay. Therefore rape isn’t a big deal to them, merely a stumbling block, even though it’s misogynistic violence against women and children (and even men too, but they don’t think men get raped).
No matter how many ” letters, cards, and text messages” the man sends, the relationship is the girl or woman’s fault. Imagine how screwed up she gets when she is told that the pursuer is the victim!
BJW and Darcy—I am a transgender woman who was sexually abused by a priest when I was an altar boy. I know firsthand of the things you say: On the Facebook page of my old Catholic school, those of us who spoke of our abuse by priests are called liars and worse, and the priests (and other perpetrators) are victims.
Rarely do I say anything good about the Catholic (or any other) church. But I must give credit to a few Catholic Church officials who are at least acknowledging, and in a few cases, doing something. That may have something to do with the fact that individual parishes report to the Diocese or Archdiocese, which in turn repot to the larger church. That is almost the exact opposite of the IFB structure Bruce describes.
MJ, I can’t hardly bear to imagine what you went through. I’m so sorry.
One would think that for these IFB churchgoers,that if they can’t bring themselves to think of ,or care about the survivors of this abuse- couldn’t they at least care about how their behavior makes God or the Bible look ? Their ridiculous defense of perpetrators only gives God and or Jesus a huge black eye. I don’t know any IFB people,but if I ever encountered any,I definitely will ask them about the above.
I remember accusations against a 40 year old youth pastor in our small town. Most people in town were sure he had molested several teenage boys, but the congregation of the church he worked for were sure he was being persecuted
“Persecuted!!” They insisted that was the issue allll over town.
He was a victim!
He ended up being prosecuted and confessed to a string of molestations going back to HIS teens.
I’m not surprised that IFB churches don’t want to do a damn thing, though.
When you teach that sexual assault is 99% the victim’s fault, that males are designed by God to be sexual aggressors, and that if a perpetrator asks God and the community for forgiveness and then they are made new, it’s no wonder sexual violence is swept under the carpet.
The CEO of any organization that was aware of rampant sexual abuse among its employees would most certainly be fired if not indicted. Yet the CEO of organized religion sits safely on his heavenly throne, immune from accountability and prosecution. He is believed by many to be able to completely stop this abuse immediately but does not, feeling it important to allow the abusers to exercise their free will to abuse others. The will of those being abused not to be abused seems unimportant.